Sheridan's postseason run came to an end on November 5 with a 25-22, 21-25, 10-25, 19-25 loss to Bloom-Carroll in a Division III regional semifinal moved to Westerville South High School's auxiliary facility due to facility issues. The Generals won the second set to level the match before Bloom-Carroll seized momentum with strong serving and a powerful attack.
Senior Mauri O'Brien led Sheridan with 15 kills, one ace, five blocks, and 10 digs in her final high school game. Drew Fox contributed 29 assists and 10 digs, and Samantha Emmert added seven kills for the Generals, who rallied late in the fourth set behind an ace from Sidney Shonk and a kill from freshman Emma Sweeney before Bloom-Carroll closed out the match.
The four-set defeat concluded a successful 21-6 campaign for Sheridan, which broke seven program records during the year and established the Generals among the elite teams in the Muskingum Valley League.